Pursuing Pear Trees and Bees

Throughout the story their eyes were watching god, Janie Crawford pursues a unique idea of love through romantic relationships, which mostly turn for the worse. Janie first creates her own idea of love while watching a bee polinate a blossoming pear tree. The perfect mutual relationship she witnesses inspires her to pursue similar relationships with others. However, her journey has a rough start, Nanny, her grandmother, forces Janie to marry Logan Killicks, a man who has almost no attractive attributes, except for his financial stability.

Logan Killicks is abusive to Janie, and mainly uses her for labor on the farm. He has no sense of humor and is mostly cold hearted. It is impossible for Janie to feel any attraction to him. He does not even seem to clean himself well. In every way this relationship does not meet Janie's expectations for love. It is a one sided relationship, where Janie seems to be on the giving end of, causing her to feel used.

One day Janie meets a man named Joe Starks, a young black man on a journey to Eatonville, where he plans to be mayor. Janie is almost immediately attracted to him, he has charm and is already talking of treating her well. To Janie, it seems that Jody represents a way out from her relationship with Logan. Jody has such big ambitions and is almost an opposite to Logan in many ways at first. So one day, while Logan is out purchasing a mule for Janie to better work the land, she runs away with Logan. It is important to note that she is running from Logan, and not to Jody, as we later see that this relationship is also destined to fail.

Joe Starks fulfills all of his ambitions as mayor of Eatonville, and more in a mad pursuit for power, however this causes him to mistreat Janie. He continues to try to shape his life exactly how he wants it, even heavily shaping Janie's life. He does not allow her to experience simple town life things, like talking to the "common" people, and instead keeps her on a pedestal. Its clear that Jody gives in to lots of societal pressures especially the sexist ones. Janie is just part of Jody's overly masculine image. This makes it all the more embarrassing when after a couple decades of being married, Jody makes Janie snap and she insults him harshly in front of their peers. This causes him to lash out and beats her. From here their relationship is never the same and Jody falls ill, and fatefully dies while Janie tells him of how badly he had treated her while visiting him on his deathbed.

Now free as ever, Janie feels complacent, and despite the advances of several men, feels little desire to pursue a relationship yet. It is only when she meets Tea Cake, Vergible Woods, does she feel a connection and think of marrying again. Janie's relationship with Tea Cake for the most part, aside from a few very notable events, is what she had dreamed of, an equal exchange of love. Janie and Tea Cake go through life together, not separated like her past relationships. In the end it seems that true love found Janie after she stopped chasing it.


Comments

  1. Hi Charles, great job on this blog post! I think your perspective regarding Janie's love life is synonymous to that of the pear-tree analogy we see placed throughout the story. I like how you brought up how Janie was often on the short-end of the stick within her marriages until she met Tea Cake, and how he enabled Janie to love without borders.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hey Charlie, great post! I think your points summarize Janie's perception of love and how they are expressed in her inevitably failed relationships. Since her vision with the pear tree, Janie imagines marriage as a poetically mutual exchange, and aims to chase after that idea for her own love life. However, her unwilling marriage to Logan Killicks shatters her fantasy. I also believe that though Janie had some interest in Joe Starks, her main objective in marrying him was to get away from Logan, so again, the marriage was unequal and disappointing. I agree with your point that when Janie stops running, true love comes to her instead. Good job!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Nice blog, we wrote about similar topics (great minds think alike)! Do you think that Janie ever reached her goal of mimicking the bees and pear tree? Teacake seemed pretty cool before the violence and stealing, but Janie also didn't seem to care too much about that anyways (according to the narrator). Was he perfect for Janie?

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hi Charlie! I think looking into Janie's relationship with Joe Starks is necessary for understanding the novel. Joe Starks is really the first man that Janie can choose for herself, and he seems perfect, although her thoughts of him could just be her being blinded by her current horrible marriage. Your post facilitates great discussion about that! Great post!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hi! I think your perspective on how love found Janie after she stopped looking for it is interesting. I agree that there was a point in the book where she just decided to be herself and focus on keeping up the store rather than on her longing for a better partner. Then as she's shooting down all these other men, Tea Cake comes into her life. I also like the way you explained her past relationships because they definitely play a key role in how she got to where she ended up.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hey Charles Richard Hechler, great post! I like how you went into depth about this recurring part of the book and the symbolism of the pear tree and the bee. So much of the book revolves around this idea for Janie, and it seems to her that by the end Tea Cake is the bee to her pear tree which was cool to see. Nice job!

    ReplyDelete
  7. Cool post! I like how you described the symbolism of the natural world around Janie and how it plays into her ideas of love and sexual desire. It's interesting how you mention that true love is only found when she stops chasing it. This idea fits with her romanticized and naturalistic view of love, where true love is found naturally rather than in an artificial setting, such as an arranged marriage. Great blog, Charles!

    ReplyDelete
  8. Great post, Charlie! I really like how you connected Janie's love life to the ongoing symbolism in Their Eyes Were Watching God -- the iconic pear tree. Janie's failed loves really built up to help her gain experience, and in the end, 'blossom' and love herself.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Nice posteroni. I really like the effort. It is quite detailed and you explain all of your points well. I also enjoyed your use of evidence from the novel to support the points you are making.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Underground Looking Up

Rebirth of the Narrator